Welcome to our Mooncottages St John Rentals Reviews page. Here you will find a library of vetted reviews from our wholesale partners Airbnb, HomeAway/VRBO and TripAdvisor/FlipKey.

Submit your review

Create your own review

Average rating:  
 36 reviews
 by Stacy K.
We are amazed at this property’s unique charm.

February 2024
We are amazed at this property’s unique charm, and how closely it matches the representation online. That happens a lot less than I’d like to say.

 by Yuri S.
What an amazing and beautiful home.

December 2023
What an amazing and beautiful home. The view is magical, the setting is pristine, and the home is perfectly styled for the vibe of the island.

 by Matthew D.
A Top Choice!

November 2023
Great views, outstanding privacy, and excellent location for experiencing the less populous side of St. John. A top choice.

 by David C.
The BEST time we ever had!

August 2023
My husband and I stayed at Mooncottage for our honeymoon. The place is amazing on all levels. The views are breathtaking and the set up of the cottage is perfect for a romantic getaway. We had the best time ever!

 by Kathy L.
Perfect spot for a romantic getaway

April 2023
Brian's place was the perfect spot for a romantic getaway for two! We especially loved the view, the secludedness, and how close we were to nature. In the future I would probably book directly through the Mooncottage website (or at least check the price there) since it will be cheaper than through Airbnb.

 by Jonathan B.
One of the most beautiful views on St. John

March 2023
One of the most beautiful views on St. John. We had a terrific, relaxing stay. A great place to curl up with a book and stare out at the ocean. The house, while compact, had everything we needed. Just to reiterate some points in the listing and other reviews: a Jeep is a must for accessing the property. Overall, a beautiful property and relaxing stay. The check-in process was fantastic and no hiccups.

 by Rebekah R
Truly an Oasis in Paradise

Sun, Apr 2 – Fri, Apr 7, 2023
We had an amazing time at the Moon Cottage, celebrating our anniversary! This home was perfect for our trip away. It provided everything we hoped for and more. We hope to return someday!!

 by Robin H
The Most Beautiful View!

Fri, Jan 13 – Sat, Jan 21, 2023
This property has by far the most beautiful view on St. John island. It is not easy to get to, but worth the view. I would caution that the villa is quite open to the out of doors. Overall we had a great time.

 by April W
Dreamy Couples Escape

Tue, Nov 29 – Sun, Dec 4, 2022
We could not have had a more intimate, romantic, secluded and connected to nature experience for our wedding/honeymoon week! Words cannot describe the beauty and breathtaking views of Mooncottage! Communication was easy and prompt on every detail before, during, and after arrival. Everything from grocery delivery to private chefs was arranged and executed without a hiccup. We will never forget our special time at Mooncottage and the feeling it gave us of being just the two of us in our own tropical paradise.

 by Mike W
Great Anniversary Spot

Fri, Jun 17 – Tue, Jun 21, 2022
This place is perfect for any honeymoon or anniversary trip. My wife and I came for our one year anniversary and had a great experience. The view from the pool and and terrace is unbelievable, especially in the morning for sunrise. Right down the hill are a bunch of little restaurants and bars, we loved Skinny Legs and Rhumb Lines. Also would recommend renting a dinghy right in Coral Bay and taking it out to Limeout for lunch. The host Janet and the on-island host/greeter Jalayne were both super friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful with any questions or needs we had. Just make sure you rent a car with 4WD.

Page 1 of 4: